For years, the gold standard for PC gaming controllers has been the official Xbox controller. It’s reliable, comfortable, and has a layout that most gamers are familiar with. But as the third-party controller market grows, is it possible to find a better option? We put two popular contenders to the test: the GameSir G7 Pro and the 8BitDo Ultimate 2 Wireless controller, to see if they can take the crown from the first-party Xbox controller.
What the Controllers Have in Common
What’s surprising is just how similar these two controllers are. They both offer a ton of features that even the official Xbox controller can’t match. Here’s a quick rundown of what you can expect from both the GameSir G7 Pro and the 8BitDo Ultimate 2 Wireless:
- Charging Dock: Both controllers come with a sleek charging dock that uses a 2.4 GHz dongle for a wireless connection. This means you can just pick up the controller from its stand and it’s instantly paired and ready to go.
- Next-Gen Tech: Both controllers feature TMR joysticks and Hall Effect triggers, which use magnetic sensors to prevent stick drift and offer incredibly precise input. They also have a 1000Hz polling rate for a super responsive, low-latency connection.
- Customization: With both controllers, you can download companion software to fine-tune your settings. You can create and save multiple profiles, adjust dead zones, and remap buttons with ease. The 8BitDo even lets you program macros, which can give you a competitive edge.
- Additional Buttons: The GameSir G7 Pro and 8BitDo Ultimate 2 Wireless each have two programmable back buttons and two extra shoulder buttons. This gives you more options for your keybindings without taking your thumb off the joystick.
While both controllers are packed with premium features and provide a comfortable, high-quality feel, there are some key differences that may influence your decision.
The GameSir G7 Pro: Clicky, Customizable, and Compatible
The GameSir G7 Pro is very similar in shape to the official Xbox controller, with a few notable differences. The first thing you’ll notice is the magnetic faceplate. This lets you easily swap it out for a different look, although additional designs aren’t available just yet. It also comes with three swappable D-pad options, so you can choose between a classic cross, a circular pad, or a hybrid version.
The G7 Pro has micro-switch buttons on the D-pad and face buttons, giving you a satisfyingly loud and tactile click with every press. It also has a unique feature that lets you remap the back buttons directly from the controller without needing to use the software. You can even lock the back buttons to prevent accidental presses.
What really sets the GameSir G7 Pro apart is its versatility. You can use it wired with an Xbox console, a feature that the 8BitDo doesn’t offer. It also has two sets of rumble motors, including haptic feedback in the triggers, just like the official Xbox controller.
The 8BitDo Ultimate 2 Wireless: Affordable and RGB
The 8BitDo Ultimate 2 Wireless controller is an excellent choice for a few reasons. First, the price is hard to beat, often coming in around $20 less than the GameSir.
The 8BitDo controller has a more traditional membrane D-pad and face buttons. While still responsive and firm, they are a lot quieter than the micro-switch buttons on the G7 Pro. The most visible difference is the built-in RGB lighting that’s completely customizable through the software and lights up as soon as you lift the controller from its dock.
Unlike the GameSir, the 8BitDo’s back buttons can only be remapped through the software. While this isn’t a deal breaker, it does mean you can’t switch key mappings on the fly. The 8BitDo also has a single, high-quality linear rumble motor, as opposed to the dual motors in the G7 Pro.
Which Controller Should You Choose?
Both the GameSir G7 Pro and the 8BitDo Ultimate 2 Wireless are fantastic third-party options that offer more features than the standard Xbox controller. They both have premium technology, comfortable designs, and a user-friendly charging system.
Ultimately, your choice comes down to personal preference. Do you prefer the tactile, clicky feel of the GameSir’s micro-switch buttons and the versatility of its swappable parts? Or do you value the sleek look of RGB lighting, the more traditional feel of membrane buttons, and a lower price point that the 8BitDo offers?
What do you look for in a PC gaming controller? Do you prefer the feel of the official Xbox controller or are you open to a third-party option?
